Sunday, April 21, 2013

Pandora Case Reflective



C Level Team,

I felt the consultants did a solid job of advising us.  There was a lot to like about their presentation. They clearly demonstrated that they deeply understood the challenges facing our company.  Currently in 2008 we have not yet generated a profit and we need to find the best ways to intelligently increase revenues and of the next two years.  I liked how the consultants addressed an array of other threats to our business.   They pointed out the obvious headwinds we are facing due to the potential dramatic increase of royalty rates from $0.0117 to $0.03.  In addition we will exhaust our funds on hand by the end of the year unless we secure additional investments and or find creative ways to grow revenues.  Another concern is that we still need to convince potential investors that our ideas and future courses of action make sense and will lead us to strong profitability.  We must keep all of these challenges present on our minds as we make important decisions that will shape our company going forward.

They outlined five possible courses of action and evaluated them in terms of dollar cost benefit.  The first alternative includes viral marketing through the use of rapidly growing social media platforms such as Facebook and MySpace.  This would aim to increase both subscription and advertising revenues and would generate a benefit of nearly $2 million over two years.  The second alternative included building a presence with applications for mobile devices in order to generate download revenues at $0.99 per download and also increase advertising revenues.  This alternative would generate an estimated benefit of $5.7 million over two years.  The third alternative was perhaps the most “radical” as it called for implementing a tiered cost structure for listener subscriptions.  The fourth alternative called for inserting 15 second audio advertisements.  This would generate an estimated benefit of approximately $10.6 million.  The fifth alternative included selling off the company for an estimate $35.1 million.

The consultants recommended we implement the second, third and fourth alternatives while opting not to pursue social media marketing or selling off the company.  I mostly agree with this recommendation but with only a slight difference of opinion.  I feel the first alternative should be pursued as well.  While the consultants have placed a relatively small figure for expected revenues through these outlets, I feel that there is a greater potential here.  The social media phenomenon is not a fad.  It’s unknown whether MySpace or Facebook will win over the larger share of consumers in the future.  But it’s clear the market for social media is here to stay.  Users have embraced the technology and I think it will only continue to increase in impact on consumer’s daily lives.  We need to align our business strategy with social media and the first alternative is an effect way to do so.  I ask that you all please strongly consider this option. 

While the third alternative of tiered structure subscriptions would generate a handsome $5.8 million benefit in two years, we need to be careful here because this is a dramatic change in how we do business.  We have positioned ourselves until now as a “free” music site for listeners.  This will be changing, as perhaps it must to ensure we remain viable.  This change must be diligently communicated to listeners to avoid a perceived exaggeration of their new costs.  We do not want to incur extra backlash from listeners because they misunderstand how the costs would apply to them.  We need to effectively communicate that there would be no costs until the 40 hour cap was met.  Then we need to make sure listeners understand the premium services they are paying for beyond this.  We don’t want them to believe they are paying for the same product they once had for free.   It needs to be understood that they are paying for a higher quality listening experience.  The point is that increased value needs to be clearly conveyed along with the increased costs.  We need to commit additional resources to our marketing and communications teams to ensure this is the message our listeners receive.  Taking these costs into consideration I think a more conservative estimate of the benefit would be appropriate—something closer to $5.5.

I think we have a good game plan moving forward here.  My belief is that we should implement the first four actions outlined above.  Now is the time to be aggressive and to commit to these actions we feel strongly about.  We must be diligent in our execution of these actions as not to alienate our loyal base of listeners through this inherently challenging period of change.  We must effectively communicate with the third alternative that listeners will now be receiving a superior listening experience for a new price.  I am excited about the future of this company and believe in this strategy that will help to take us there.

Bobby

No comments:

Post a Comment