Sunday, March 10, 2013

Accenture COBIT 5 Reflective


Fellow Executives,


We find ourselves as a company on high ground and a stable footing.  Accenture has come a very long way over the past decade and we have much to be proud of.  In our industry, we boast the lowest IT expense as a percentage of revenues.  We have the lowest IT workforce as a percentage of headcount as well as the lowest IT expense per employee.  While driving these costs into the basement we have seen our revenues more than double over that period of time, peaking at $28 billion in 2012 (1).  Our success is largely driven by our core values which remind us not to rest on our laurels.  We need always to stay sharp and a step ahead of our competition.  To do this we find creative ways to add value to our company by improving our operations and refining our processes and structures.  This is a real challenge.  We must take painstaking care in the decisions we make to optimize our business.  These decisions require our undivided attention.  Initiatives taken without proper due diligence or implemented carelessly have the ability to destroy value exponentially faster than they are capable of creating it.  We must prudently evaluate our decision at hand and uphold a commitment that any projects we pursue receive nothing but the highest level of disciplined implementation.  With that said I would like to briefly discuss my take on consultant presentation and provide my recommendation for COBIT 5.

The consultants really did a solid job examining our current IT governance and juxtaposing it with a potential COBIT 5 implementation.    The consultants did a great job of helping us understand what the COBIT 5 framework is and the 7 phases of its implementation.   We saw how COBIT 5 acts as an umbrella of IT governance that covers multiple key areas of an IT organization in helping to promote its goals.  Albeit a tested and proven framework, COBIT 5 does not fit and does not complement our organization at this time.  If I was to look at COBIT 5 roughly 10 or 12 years ago my thoughts would like be, “yes this makes sense.”  The reason why now is not the time is because we already built and handsomely customize our existing IT framework over the past decade.  COBIT 5 is a generalized framework that as the consultants described “tries to fit a box around IT governance.”  This may have been a great asset to us a decade ago when we were redefining and overhauling our business and IT governance.  At this point in time COBIT 5 would not greatly benefit us because we have already established sound IT governance and are leveraging this to provide highly tailored solutions to our clientele.  Think of COBIT 5 as the foundation of a house.  Picture us as homeowners looking to accent and refine our state-of-the art home.  We are perhaps looking to tweak our color schemes or upgrade our exterior fixtures; not reconstruct our home from the ground up.  What I’m saying is COBIT 5 simply doesn’t fit to our needs at this time.

When we weigh the costs, I think the decision not to implement COBIT 5 becomes even clearer.  Considering training costs, programming and added IT personnel the costs incurred in the first year would be approximately $17.5 million.  Over a three year implementation period these costs total up to $49 million.   Without a clear and quantifiable benefit, I don’t see an existing business justification for this $49 million investment in COBIT 5.  While I do not feel COBIT 5 is the right project for us at this time, I do think we should continue to look into other options going forward.  We would be wise to hone our project investigation to initiatives that might help enhance an already well-oiled machine.  We are not in overhaul mode at this time.  We need to optimize in order to make what we do well even better.  We need to see if we can possibly gain better effectiveness and stronger discipline with the current activities we are taking.  Creating positive change does not necessary require we change ‘what’ we are doing in terms of processes, but perhaps rather the ‘how’ we are doing it.  Given the quality of this presentation I suggest we relay these points to those same consultants.  I am confident they will circle back with better fitting recommendations for us to examine.



(1)    http://finance.yahoo.com/q/ks?s=ACN+Key+Statistics
 

Monday, March 4, 2013

Zara Reflective



C-Level team,

                The consultants we hired provided a very professional presentation for us yesterday.  I also feel we asked a number of inquisitive questions that parlayed some interesting feedback.  Before I delve into the takeaways of the presentation or provide my own critiques, I want to impress upon our group that we must very carefully consider any decisions we make at this crossroads.  The magnitude of a decision to potentially update our operating systems, POS terminals or install wireless networks would resonate far beyond the associated investment costs.   This decision could impact and reshape our current business model and or the culture of our company, and not necessarily for the better.   As such, I challenge you to analyze this situation from all angles and to use your critical judgment when evaluating the consultant presentation.

                The consultants strongly urged us to make a move at this point in time to update our operating system to Linux.  They also insisted there was a need for us to upgrade our POS terminals and install a wireless network that would allow our stores to electronically “speak” to one another.  I feel the group did a solid job of providing cost analysis for this alternative to help us understand what this investment would require.  They provided a decent roadmap for how we would unfold this plan, which they suggested be done in phases.   However, what I do not agree with in principal is their belief that our company needs to make an upgrade at this time.  Personally, I do not see how the benefits they preached would outweigh the costs.  I also do not believe the benefits the consultants harped on, specifically an enhanced ability to manage inventory even applies to our business model.  Allow me to further explain my point.   Inventory management for our business is not a crucial necessity.  In my eyes it’s little beyond a “nice to have.”  We gain a competitive advantage by minimizing our inventories altogether.  This is clearly reflected in our Current Assets which were only 1.1€ billion in 2002.  Our current assets are nearly half that of our competitor Benetton—a company whom we surpassed in revenues by 200% for that same period.  The culture of our company and the competitive niche we exploit revolves around our ability to be the first responder to fashion demand.  We are not a company that invests heavily in promoting fashion trends.  We allow demand to develop organically then we immediately respond by allowing this demand to “pull” the appropriate supply through our value chain which we have full vertical integration of.  Thus what sets us apart from our peers is that we do not have to make an educated guess on supply.  We do not have to actively manage inventory surpluses as others do when their supply significantly overshoots demand.  The way we operate and the way we succeed does not stand to significantly benefit from inventory management enhancements brought forth by the consultant’s recommendations.

We maintain an 80€ million cost advantage over our average competitor due to the fact that our DOS operating system allows us to maintain a simplistic and incredibly low maintenance IT infrastructure.  As a result our IT spending is only 0.5% of our total revenues while our average competitor spends 2.5% of revenues.   Yet, I am not blind to the fact that our DOS operating system is a dinosaur.  As the consultants highlighted for us, while our hardware vendor has not stated they would discontinue providing DOS compatible equipment they neither contractually agreed they would continue to make it available further into the future.  If our hardware vendor ceases to continue providing DOS compatible equipment we can expect that our new store opening will come to a screeching halt for at least 6 months while we scramble to port our terminals with a new operating system.  At our current pace of opening one new store per day this would translate to a loss in future revenues to the tune of 900€ million.  This risk is not to be ignored.  We need to prepare ourselves for the day—it’s coming, we just don’t know when—our DOS operating system reaches extinction.   What we must do is be ready.  This means we need to complete the 15,000 hours of programing time needed to port a terminal with a new operating system.  We need to perform a handful of test upgrades to a small sample of our current and new stores so that we can be fluid at performing upgrades at a grander scale when it ultimately becomes necessary.  Contrary to the consultants advising, I feel Microsoft Windows would be the go-to operating system for porting and test upgrades.  Window’s price at 140€ per license and 30€ per year in maintenance is competitive with the other option of Unix and Linux.  For our testing purposes we would only need to purchase around 75 licenses for 15 sample stores, meaning the total cost would be approximately 12,750€ for software licenses and maintenance.  The hardware for new terminals would cost 390,000€ pushing the total costs for software and hardware up 400,000€.  We would hire a small team of 5 to 10 IT employees who will focus on testing out new operating systems at a strategic sample of 5 current and 10 new store locations.  I estimate these measures would increase our annual IT spend by at most 5€ million.  This team could complete the port in 18 months.  In 2 years they would have us fully prepared to make upgrades to new stores at a moment’s notice should it become necessary.   They would also be fully prepared to lead upgrades at our current establishments.  

To sum up, we could eliminate our current 900€ million revenue exposure by investing 400€ thousand in technical resources and 5€ million per year in IT specialists.  Meanwhile we can continue to ride out a nearly 75€ million per year IT cost advantage over our competition for as long as DOS remains only an endangered species. 

Sunday, March 3, 2013

Accenture Preparation



Fellow Executives,

We have every reason to be proud of the total transformation our company has accomplished over the past twelve years.  While we more than doubled our headcount to 180,000 employees during this period we managed to reduce our IT spend per person by 69%.  Our revenues have nearly doubled in that time reaching $21.6 Billion in 2010 while we simultaneously reduced our IT spend as a ratio of those revenues by 59%.  We streamlined our IT operations by moving to a single technology platform provided by Microsoft.  This has allowed us to slash our number of global applications nearly in half down to 365.  We drastically reduced our number of local applications by 87% of what they were in 2001.  

These impressive outcomes are a direct result of the new philosophical approaches and governing structures we’ve successfully melded into our business strategy.  We adapted our traditional cost center IT approach to one where IT functions as an efficient business within our business.  This has helped us eliminate waste by delivering a more precise level of support from a tiered offering of services that more accurately meets the needs and price points of both our internal and external clients.  Our one-vendor approach and use of outsourcing and Global Delivery Network has contributed to a significant level of cost savings while allowing us to maintain a flexible and versatility staffed organization.   Fundamental to our new method of decision making is an evaluation of critical business justification and return on investment qualifications that are required for IT projects before any commitment of resources.  These criteria coupled with a fresh standard of accountability now imposed by our ROI auditing process has aided us in more appropriately allocating our IT resources by subduing political influences.   And the common thread woven through all areas of our transformation has been our sense of creativity and our ability to keep looking ahead for opportunities to continue improving.  This core characteristic has lead us to the intriguing question we now ask ourselves; is 2013 the appropriate time for our company to undertake another transformational leap by implementing COBIT 5?  Considering our current business needs and operating approach I evaluated the incremental benefits a potential move to COBIT 5 might yield.  I likewise quantified the applicable costs stemming from this option.  Cumulative consideration of the costs and benefits reveals it would not be a profitable decision for Accenture to implement COBIT 5 at this time.

COBIT, an acronym for “Control Objectives for Information and related Technology” is a framework designed by ISAC A for IT management and IT governance, which defines a set of generic processes and control objectives that helps business managers , IT and assurance professionals manage IT (1).  The current 5th version of COBIT was released just last year.  To avoid providing an excess of background detail, I’ll lastly mention that the COBIT framework seeks to classify IT activities into four key domains: Plan and Organize, Acquire and Implement, Deliver and Support, and Monitor and Evaluate (2).   There then exists a detailed sublevel of specific processes and controls under each of these four domains.  As I researched the topic it became increasingly evident to me that our existing approach to IT management and governance draws striking parallels to the framework and best practices outlined by COBIT.  Many of the benefits COBIT seeks to bestow we are in fact already realizing as a product of our IT transformation.   For example, a key goal of COBIT is to link IT processes with business requirements. Because we now run our IT function like a business we already experience this linkage.  For example we now provide IT help on a per needs basis at $20 per call incurred by the internal “customer” with a specific business need that justifies their willingness to absorb the charge for service.  Marrying our IT services with business requirements has allowed us to minimize IT office staffing and dramatically reduce support costs.  This COBIT goal is already something we do quite well.  Another benefit COBIT seeks to enact is a common denominator of platforms and processes throughout an organization.  Our adoption of the one-vendor single platform approach has greatly accomplished this objective for our company, which can be seen through the overall reduction and streamlining of our applications.  This is another area we are currently proficient in.  A third goal of COBIT is to assign responsibility, measure performance and form cohesive processes.  Our current IT governance ensures project sponsors roles continue beyond proposal by attaching responsibility through all phases of the project including accountability for extracting value.  Our annual ROI auditing process requires performance standards are measured and maintained.  Finally, our managers are asked to wear two “hats” during project proposal meetings, whereby they consider the project impacts on not only their immediate function but also the company at large.  Our company does not have a distinct need or area of concern that could be fulfilled by COBIT.

The cost consideration of a COBIT implementation includes training materials as well as two day training classes for participants.  The cost of training materials is approximately $175 per person (3).  The cost of the two day class is approximately $1500 (4).  Factoring in travel and accommodation expenses raises the total per person training cost to $2675.  If we went this route we would likely introduce 5% of our staff or 9,000 people to this initial training.  This would include primarily middle and upper management positions spanning our Business Operations, Infrastructure Services, Business Application Delivery Front Office Applications, and Business Application Delivery Applications segments.  At $2675 per person multiplied by 9,000 the direct costs associated with delivering the initial COBIT 5 training amounts to $24,075,000.  This is a substantial amount of money to invest in a program that I do not see us having a considerable need for at this point in time.  In addition, certain reviews have made claims that “COBIT can be difficult to understand and even more difficult to implement (2).”  While that alone is something to consider when making a $24 million investment, I still come back to my previous point that there does not appear to be a justifiable business need for our company for COBIT 5.  One of the contributing factors to our company’s recent success has been our ability to create value through prudent allocation of resources in response to a specific business need.   That same logic is applicable in evaluating this case for COBIT.  A specific business need does not exist for this company that would justify allocating $24 million of our IT resources to a COBIT implementation.

Saturday, March 2, 2013

Ubuntu


Mr. Ducksworth,

                I have researched and experimented with the Ubuntu operating system.  I would like to share with you my thoughts on Ubuntu as a potential candidate computer operating system for company.

                Ubuntu is a popular desktop ready Linux operating system that’s free of license fees or charges because it leverages open source software.  From a features and capabilities standpoint Ubuntu is a fair alternative to our current the Microsoft Windows 7 operating system.  Ubuntu can be loaded onto a PC using a DVD created from the internet.  While I consider myself only an intermediately skilled computer user, I found Ubuntu was relatively user friendly.  It was an easy adjustment for me after only an hour or two of trial.   Speedy and reliable web browsing was available through the readily installed Firefox browser.  Ubuntu and Firefox provide excellent web security with automatic security updates, anti-phishing technology and guards against malware and viruses.  Ubuntu also supports the Google Chrome browser.   Ubuntu’s LibreOffice provides a package of word processing, spreadsheet and presentation tools similar to the Microsoft Office applications that our employees utilize routinely.  Ubuntu is fully compatible with Microsoft Word, Excel and PowerPoint so employees will be able to access, update and share their existing files.  Ubuntu also supports Adobe for PDF document capabilities.  Thunderbird email application provides the essential email, contact and calendar functionalities; albeit less extensive capabilities than our current Microsoft Outlook system.  A multitude of additional applications (many free of cost) are available for free download through the Ubuntu Software Centre.  While not particularly straightforward to sync up, I did find that Ubuntu is capable of running our SAP ERP and Oracle business software (1) (2).   Finally, helpful technical and application support is available via wide reaching free ‘Community’ forums that would be suitable for handling the bulk of our user issues.

From a cost benefit standpoint I don’t see a financial justification for switching over to Ubuntu.   Right now Microsoft Windows 7 operating system costs us $100 to purchase off the shelf for new installations.  Yet there’s only a marginal $50 savings to be gained in purchasing a laptop without Windows 7 operating system (3).  Per our IT budget we expect to purchase 50 new laptops over the next two years for the planned new hires.  This translates to maximum potential savings of $2,500 if all 50 are purchased without Microsoft 7.  The existing laptops used by our 500 employees have been upgraded to Windows 7 not long ago.  The $50,000 we spent for those licenses has already been incurred as a sunk cost.  There is no way to recoup any of this expense by transitioning these laptops to Ubuntu.  As I stated before it took me a couple hours of playing around with Ubuntu before I really knew what I was doing.  We would have to factor in loss in productivity costs stemming from a short learning curve period.  I conservatively estimate this cost would amount to $45,000 – considering a 2 hour loss in productivity for each of our 500 employees who are earning an average wage of $45 per hour.

In conclusion, I find Ubuntu is an interesting alternative to our current Windows operating system which provides a like comparison for system features and capabilities necessary for our business.  However, I do not think it makes financial sense for us to switch over to Ubuntu considering the potential contributed cost savings of $2,500 would be substantially outweighed by the estimated $45,000 in switching costs related to temporary loss in productivity.  A switch to Ubuntu would likely generate a net loss of $42,500 for our company over the next two years.  I advise we do not pursue a move to Ubuntu at this time.  But I do suggest we revisit and evaluate Ubuntu again in 3 or 4 years when it becomes necessary for us to upgrade our operating systems from Windows 7.