Sunday, March 10, 2013

Accenture COBIT 5 Reflective


Fellow Executives,


We find ourselves as a company on high ground and a stable footing.  Accenture has come a very long way over the past decade and we have much to be proud of.  In our industry, we boast the lowest IT expense as a percentage of revenues.  We have the lowest IT workforce as a percentage of headcount as well as the lowest IT expense per employee.  While driving these costs into the basement we have seen our revenues more than double over that period of time, peaking at $28 billion in 2012 (1).  Our success is largely driven by our core values which remind us not to rest on our laurels.  We need always to stay sharp and a step ahead of our competition.  To do this we find creative ways to add value to our company by improving our operations and refining our processes and structures.  This is a real challenge.  We must take painstaking care in the decisions we make to optimize our business.  These decisions require our undivided attention.  Initiatives taken without proper due diligence or implemented carelessly have the ability to destroy value exponentially faster than they are capable of creating it.  We must prudently evaluate our decision at hand and uphold a commitment that any projects we pursue receive nothing but the highest level of disciplined implementation.  With that said I would like to briefly discuss my take on consultant presentation and provide my recommendation for COBIT 5.

The consultants really did a solid job examining our current IT governance and juxtaposing it with a potential COBIT 5 implementation.    The consultants did a great job of helping us understand what the COBIT 5 framework is and the 7 phases of its implementation.   We saw how COBIT 5 acts as an umbrella of IT governance that covers multiple key areas of an IT organization in helping to promote its goals.  Albeit a tested and proven framework, COBIT 5 does not fit and does not complement our organization at this time.  If I was to look at COBIT 5 roughly 10 or 12 years ago my thoughts would like be, “yes this makes sense.”  The reason why now is not the time is because we already built and handsomely customize our existing IT framework over the past decade.  COBIT 5 is a generalized framework that as the consultants described “tries to fit a box around IT governance.”  This may have been a great asset to us a decade ago when we were redefining and overhauling our business and IT governance.  At this point in time COBIT 5 would not greatly benefit us because we have already established sound IT governance and are leveraging this to provide highly tailored solutions to our clientele.  Think of COBIT 5 as the foundation of a house.  Picture us as homeowners looking to accent and refine our state-of-the art home.  We are perhaps looking to tweak our color schemes or upgrade our exterior fixtures; not reconstruct our home from the ground up.  What I’m saying is COBIT 5 simply doesn’t fit to our needs at this time.

When we weigh the costs, I think the decision not to implement COBIT 5 becomes even clearer.  Considering training costs, programming and added IT personnel the costs incurred in the first year would be approximately $17.5 million.  Over a three year implementation period these costs total up to $49 million.   Without a clear and quantifiable benefit, I don’t see an existing business justification for this $49 million investment in COBIT 5.  While I do not feel COBIT 5 is the right project for us at this time, I do think we should continue to look into other options going forward.  We would be wise to hone our project investigation to initiatives that might help enhance an already well-oiled machine.  We are not in overhaul mode at this time.  We need to optimize in order to make what we do well even better.  We need to see if we can possibly gain better effectiveness and stronger discipline with the current activities we are taking.  Creating positive change does not necessary require we change ‘what’ we are doing in terms of processes, but perhaps rather the ‘how’ we are doing it.  Given the quality of this presentation I suggest we relay these points to those same consultants.  I am confident they will circle back with better fitting recommendations for us to examine.



(1)    http://finance.yahoo.com/q/ks?s=ACN+Key+Statistics
 

No comments:

Post a Comment