Monday, April 22, 2013

Harrah's Reflective



C Level Team,

The consultants did a fine job with their presentation earlier today.  Our company has embraced a strategy that has provided us with results.  We have earned a competitive advantage in the gaming industry by investing heavily in Information systems that provide us with valuable marketing insights.  Our $100 million investment in IT has paid us back with an ROI of 62%.  Meanwhile our competitors have gone a different route by investing nearly a combined $1 billion in extravagant properties yielding an ROI between 15 to 23%.  In light of this success, we really gave this consultant group a difficult challenge by insisting they advise us on how we continue to improve a very high performing company.  We challenged them to come up with intelligent projects that will push us even further ahead of the competition.  The consultants came up with three ideas, which while I feel are good ideas, I believe they are very interdependent on one another.   I also feel there are a few gaps that need to be bridged.  Allow me to explain.

The consultant’s first project recommendation involves increasing our data mining activities.  This calls for further sharpening our focus on the “right” type of customers who have the highest payoff potential.  These are people who typically spend $500 or more per visit and make roughly 3 visits to our casinos per year.  I agree in concept that we can benefit from digging deeper to better understand what the information has to tell us.  However, I feel that in order to perform better analytic than we are currently doing, it will require an up scaled allocation of resources.  This means enhancing the capabilities of both our systems and our people.  The Enterprise server examined in project number three would be a necessity in my belief in order to take our data mining to the next level.  The suggested IBM system would carry a cost of $50,000 to install.  We would also need to hire at least one seasoned analytic expert and provide for further training for our current team members.  I estimate there would be roughly $250,000 in costs for this in the first year, considering the $125,000 salary for the expert and another $5000 to train our other 25 market and data analysts.  Thereafter we would only incur the additional costs of the lead expert’s salary.  I am not arguing against undertaking the data mining project.  I am merely acknowledging that I believe it would require considerable investments beyond the stated costs of the mailing list ($1,250) and marketing efforts ($210 per customer offer).

I am very keen on the second project recommendation to implement the online reservation and concierge.  I think this is a direct way to reach our loyal customers and act as a tool to potentially nudge them to make an additional 4th visit to our casino per year.  An extra visit would mean an additional $500 in revenue per customer.  I think this project would be most effective if coupled with both the first and third projects.  By enhancing our analytics and data mining we could aim to identify the time of year in which a customer might be most vulnerable to make an additional trip to our casino.  Perhaps single people in their 30’s might be more prone to visiting a casino around Valentine’s day.  Or perhaps a married couple who frequents a casino could be a good target during to point this resource to for their Anniversary weekend.  I am confident there are patterns that exist in data we could mine that would allow us to make even more effective use of the online reservation and concierge tool than the consultants suggested.

I would like to consider all three of these projects.  However, I would like to have a better understanding of the total benefit and cost of implementing all three of them in tandem.  I would like to ask if the consultants wouldn’t mind providing us with a high level summary of this request.  I feel we can then take a keener look at what we could expect to incrementally gain from taking these these three projects on all as one.

Regards,
Bobby

Sunday, April 21, 2013

Pandora Case Reflective



C Level Team,

I felt the consultants did a solid job of advising us.  There was a lot to like about their presentation. They clearly demonstrated that they deeply understood the challenges facing our company.  Currently in 2008 we have not yet generated a profit and we need to find the best ways to intelligently increase revenues and of the next two years.  I liked how the consultants addressed an array of other threats to our business.   They pointed out the obvious headwinds we are facing due to the potential dramatic increase of royalty rates from $0.0117 to $0.03.  In addition we will exhaust our funds on hand by the end of the year unless we secure additional investments and or find creative ways to grow revenues.  Another concern is that we still need to convince potential investors that our ideas and future courses of action make sense and will lead us to strong profitability.  We must keep all of these challenges present on our minds as we make important decisions that will shape our company going forward.

They outlined five possible courses of action and evaluated them in terms of dollar cost benefit.  The first alternative includes viral marketing through the use of rapidly growing social media platforms such as Facebook and MySpace.  This would aim to increase both subscription and advertising revenues and would generate a benefit of nearly $2 million over two years.  The second alternative included building a presence with applications for mobile devices in order to generate download revenues at $0.99 per download and also increase advertising revenues.  This alternative would generate an estimated benefit of $5.7 million over two years.  The third alternative was perhaps the most “radical” as it called for implementing a tiered cost structure for listener subscriptions.  The fourth alternative called for inserting 15 second audio advertisements.  This would generate an estimated benefit of approximately $10.6 million.  The fifth alternative included selling off the company for an estimate $35.1 million.

The consultants recommended we implement the second, third and fourth alternatives while opting not to pursue social media marketing or selling off the company.  I mostly agree with this recommendation but with only a slight difference of opinion.  I feel the first alternative should be pursued as well.  While the consultants have placed a relatively small figure for expected revenues through these outlets, I feel that there is a greater potential here.  The social media phenomenon is not a fad.  It’s unknown whether MySpace or Facebook will win over the larger share of consumers in the future.  But it’s clear the market for social media is here to stay.  Users have embraced the technology and I think it will only continue to increase in impact on consumer’s daily lives.  We need to align our business strategy with social media and the first alternative is an effect way to do so.  I ask that you all please strongly consider this option. 

While the third alternative of tiered structure subscriptions would generate a handsome $5.8 million benefit in two years, we need to be careful here because this is a dramatic change in how we do business.  We have positioned ourselves until now as a “free” music site for listeners.  This will be changing, as perhaps it must to ensure we remain viable.  This change must be diligently communicated to listeners to avoid a perceived exaggeration of their new costs.  We do not want to incur extra backlash from listeners because they misunderstand how the costs would apply to them.  We need to effectively communicate that there would be no costs until the 40 hour cap was met.  Then we need to make sure listeners understand the premium services they are paying for beyond this.  We don’t want them to believe they are paying for the same product they once had for free.   It needs to be understood that they are paying for a higher quality listening experience.  The point is that increased value needs to be clearly conveyed along with the increased costs.  We need to commit additional resources to our marketing and communications teams to ensure this is the message our listeners receive.  Taking these costs into consideration I think a more conservative estimate of the benefit would be appropriate—something closer to $5.5.

I think we have a good game plan moving forward here.  My belief is that we should implement the first four actions outlined above.  Now is the time to be aggressive and to commit to these actions we feel strongly about.  We must be diligent in our execution of these actions as not to alienate our loyal base of listeners through this inherently challenging period of change.  We must effectively communicate with the third alternative that listeners will now be receiving a superior listening experience for a new price.  I am excited about the future of this company and believe in this strategy that will help to take us there.

Bobby

Monday, April 15, 2013

From Pandora to Profit



            Pandora finds itself at all-important cross roads where the strategic decisions it makes in the next year or two will have a lasting impact on the viability and profit potential of the company.  Pandora founder and chief strategist Tim Westergren has managed to honor his core philosophies while creating a music industry phenomenon.  But in hiring new CEO Joe Kennedy he has come to terms with the fact that Pandora needs to inject strategic creativity to grow substantial revenues.  Since launching in 1999, the user base has ballooned to 8 million now in 2007, and online hours continue to grow at a rate of 50% year over year.  Pandora has proven its worth to advertisers.  Yet the company has failed to produce a profit and fully convince venture capitalists their business model is for real.  Joe and Tim need to drive profitability by amplifying their advertising power, charging fees for upstart musicians, and enhancing the automation of their song coding system.

Pandora earns an effective cost per thousand impressions (CPM) in the $10-13 range, which is considered strong for Web advertising.  Currently this translates to 3.58 cents of advertising revenue per hour.  Pandora has great opportunity to increase these marks to strengthen advertising revenue.  Pandora appeals to advertisers for several reasons.  First is because of the large volumes of users who visit their site.  More importantly, Pandora has the ability to target advertisements at the moments when users interact with the site increasing the likelihood they will see and react to an ad.  And most importantly, Pandora can offer advertisers information about a specific user’s age, gender, zip code and the type of music they listen to which provides valuable personality insights.   Joe and Tim could still increase the advertising value of Pandora by gathering more extensive information on each Pandora user.   Pandora should require each user to fill out a 5 to 10 minute survey containing 50 key questions and insights desired by advertisers.  Acknowledging Pandora’s high level of user loyalty – demonstrated through the 1 million letters they sent to congress to fight license increases—it is doubtful there would be strong outcry or resistance to the survey.  Pandora could even position the survey to its loyal fans as a collaborative effort on their behalf to help keep Pandora a free service for them.  An increase in advertising value from $10-13 CPM to the $14-16 range would translate to a 25% increase in advertising revenue per hour.  With hours doubling year over year this effect would be dramatically compounded.  By implementing the mandatory surveys Pandora could inject further revenues with minimal risk.

Another low risk method for growing revenues includes charging fees to upstart and emerging musicians in exchange for making their music available on Pandora.  Pandora receives several hundred CDs from “unknown” artists every week.  New artists who are able to get on Pandora openly acknowledged the value and benefits they received by doing so.  One artist exclaims, “I just wanted to thank you for putting my music into your system.  I have had sales all over the U.S. and Europe from people who found me via your site…I can’t believe what a promotional tool Pandora has become for my music.”  The dominant record labels are interested only in pursing the exceptionally rare “big-hit” artists. Pandora exists as one of the few mediums available to unknown artists trying to reach the masses of interested listeners.  Pandora needs to be rewarded for opportunities for success it is currently creating for upstart musicians.  There is little risk this strategy would backfire; due to the fact unknown artists have such limited opportunities to pursue in the first place in order to promote their music.   Pandora should institute a $100 charge known as an “entrance fee” per album loaded into their system.  This would generate an additional $2.6 million per year in revenues, assuming Pandora receives 500 new albums per week.

A third strategy involves investing to implement an automated song coding process.  This is important because it has the opportunity to increase the speed at which songs can be added to the Pandora library – meaning higher volumes “entrance fees” which could be processed each period.  This would also have the potential to reduce headcount in the long term.  Currently the coding process relies on a large team of analysts and is a time and labor intensive process.  Currently Pandora employs 100 people, of which we will assume 25 works on the all-important coding process.   Assuming these employees make on average $75,000 this translates to $1,875,000 per year in coding salaries.  If Pandora made a one-time investment of $1 million to develop an automated coding program that could reduce this team to only 5 heads then it would save $375,000 in this first year and  $1.5 million every year going forward.

Pandora is poised to become a profit generating machine that could consume a healthy market share of the music industry.  To realize this potential Pandora needs to implement creative strategies in the immediate future that will increase revenues and profitability.  By enriching the depth and quality of consumer information with mandatory user surveys Pandora could increase its advertising revenues by 25%.  By charging unknown artists an entrance fees they could cash in on the discovery benefits they are currently providing these artists for free.  This would potentially generate $2.6 in additional revenues per year.    Finally, Tim and Joe should invest $1 million in technology to bring serious automation to the coding process which could save the company $6.375 million over the next 5 years.

Regards,
Bobby

Sunday, April 14, 2013

Raising the Stakes for Harrah's

The challenge facing Harrah’s revolves around how to best increase profitability, while continuing to grow the geographic footprint and market share of the company.   Harrah’s needed to adopt an innovative strategy to allow it to distinguish itself from the competition in order to capture a larger share of the gaming industry’s profits.

                Entrance into new gaming markets that included Indian reservations and riverboats was paramount to its geographic expansion.  With 21 casinos across America employing 40,000 and serving 19 million customers Harrah’s had fortified its presence in the gaming industry.  
Harrah’s still needed to find creative ways to gain a competitive advantage and distinguish itself from flashy competitors like Bellagio and Paris, which had invested enormous dollars in lavish hotels, shopping malls and attractions.   Harrah’s decided to implement a brand approach for its 21 casinos.  This was a radically different from the industry standard, whereby most properties operated as independent fiefdoms that were allowed to autonomously reside over their marketing strategies.  Harrah’s instituted commonalities in the gambling experience to fortify their brand image.  These included the recognition and reward programs aimed to foster consumer loyalty and encourage the frequency of customer visits, profitability per visit and cross-market play.
To capitalize on their strategy to deliver the highest level of customer service Harrah’s had to develop better methods to understand and manage their customer relationships.   Harrah’s understood necessity of analyzing customer behaviors and preferences and acknowledged the substantial investment in integrated information technology platforms it would have to make.   By investing $100 million in computers and software Harrah’s developed the most sophisticated “frequent bettor” program in the industry.   Focal to this was the development of WINet which enabled “closed loop marketing” where scientific data-driven campaigns could be developed, tested and the results could be retained for future use.   WINet collected customer data from various source systems and integrated the data around the customer.  This helped identify market segments and customer profiles which could be targeted with specific offers that would be more impactful and enhance profitability with this use of “intelligent” marketing.

The alternative actions available to Harrah’s included the preexisting manual methods of combing and analyzing data in order to develop customer offers.  The basic systems in place like the Informix database had helped keep IT costs from ballooning but did not enable the advanced analytics required to perform closed loop marketing.  The counter alternative was to invest heavily in a full scale customer relationship management system such as WINet.  From this point forward, there is yet another consideration to further advance the capabilities and utilization of the system with the aim of increasing profitability and sustained growth.

Evaluation of the alternative option to invest further to enhance the WINet system should take into consideration the impact of similar investments made to date.  The results of WINet are tangible and significant.  Harrah’s stock price has risen steadily while their earnings have doubled over the past year.  Same store sales revenue grew 14% in 1999 which translates to a $242 million increase over the prior year.  Harrah’s grew their revenues faster than their competition nearly everywhere they did business.  Total Rewards and cross marketing of the brand have produced a 62% internal rate of return on investments in IT. 

The results clearly demonstrate the $100 million investment in information systems upgrades have paid off handsomely for Harrah’s.  With this evidence in hand, my recommendation to Harrah’s would be to continue to distance themselves from a marketing and operations leadership position through further investments to hone their systems.   The Marketing Workbench (MWB) is an example of a sound application which could be further built upon.  By enhancing the MWB storage capability beyond the 90 day daily detail limit and the monthly range beyond 24 months analysts could perform even deeper analysis of its customer base to truly understand how the tastes and trends of its most valued customers may change over time.   Another area of improvement relates to the speed at which offers may be generated.   Additional specific offers generated and sent in real time to customers while playing could help extend the length of visits.  The expansion of mobile technology and increased use of smart phones would act as a facilitator for this aim.  This could help drive up the profitability per visit measurements.   

There are several hard pieces of evidence that give strength to this recommendation.  First and foremost is the 62% internal rate of return on IT investments gives credence to further optimizing the capabilities of the systems that support closed loop marketing.  The increase in customer retention worth several million dollars cannot be ignored.  Harrah’s has doubled their response rate to offers and streamlined its guest rewards and recognition programs across properties while establishing a brand identity.   The right investments in IT have increased profitability by more than $50 million!  Harrah’s has made the right investments and the proof is in the pudding.  The competition will look to close the competitive gap by simulating what Harrah’s has done successfully.  Harrah’s must not only leverage its existing technology but continues to find ways to enhance and evolve it’s functions so that it can maintain its competitive advantage.

Regards,
Bobby

Monday, April 1, 2013

Microsoft Project Evaluation



Mr. Spacely,

I’ve prepared the requested evaluation of Microsoft Project as a potential tool for our large innovative packaging solutions company.  As you may know, Microsoft Project is a popular project management software program that assists in developing plans, allocating resources, controlling budgets, and managing progress and workloads.   I’ve considered Microsoft Project on the basis of adoption and assimilation, applicability with our business needs and structure, and cost-benefit comparison.  The results of this analysis indicate Microsoft Project would be a worthwhile investment for our company

                According to ValleySpeak Project Server, “Microsoft Project is undoubtedly the most popular project management software around” (1).   A main reason for why Project is a top seller has to do with the fact it integrates and shares features with the Microsoft cornerstone applications including Word, Excel and PowerPoint.  For example, the 2010 and 2013 editions now include the well know ‘Ribbons’ that has become a helpful and familiar feature for Microsoft users.  I call attention to this point because as you also know, our company currently operates on the Microsoft Office software platform.  Our 1500 SG&A and R&D employees have established a sound foundation with the Microsoft Office 2010 applications.  This would create a learning curve benefit that translates to meaningful productivity savings in the event we chose to implement Microsoft Project.  In the words of Bright Hub Project Management,  “Many project managers like Microsoft Project because it’s relatively easy to learn, as long as you’ve already used Microsoft Windows and other Microsoft products” (2).  I estimate users would require approximately 8 hours of focused self-practice in order to reach an adequate level of comfort and proficiency with Microsoft Project.   For 1500 employees at an average wage of $45 per hour times 8 hours this equates to a total of $540,000 in productivity losses related to assimilation with Microsoft Office.  While this is significant, a comparable product like Oracle’s Primavera P6 might potentially take three times as long to attain proficiency.  That equates to a cost of $1,620,000.  This means there is an estimated productivity savings discount of $1,080,000 that we can realize by choosing Microsoft Project versus a competitive alternative.

                I evaluated Microsoft Project in terms of compatibility with our business operations to see whether it’s a sensible fit for us.   An online resource by the name of Project Assistants explained there are critical criteria “that would indicate whether or not there is favorable ROI for implementing Microsoft Project”, which hinges on the organization’s “number of projects, complexity of projects, and how much the organization has to invest” (3).  According to Project Assistants, “Your organization needs to run at least ten simultaneous projects for there to be enough complexity to necessitate software such as Microsoft Project Server 2010” (3).  Last year we deployed 75 high potential R&D projects as well as 50 other major projects across our SG&A departments.   Projects spanning wider geographic areas or those which are less predictable or repeatable are better candidates for Microsoft Project (3).  Our company’s operations span the globe and most of our projects are highly specific initiatives or large and complex collaborations.   “The more your organization invests in projects, the more value there is in reducing risk in your projects.  Your organization needs to measure budgets in the millions for there to be enough at stake to be worth implementing technology into the project management process” (3).  Our SG&A and R&D budgets are in the hundreds of millions.  Last year we invested nearly $500 million in R&D and another $700 million in SG&A.  Nearly one third of this spending was related to projects alone.  Our company is of adequate size and our projects are of scope and complexity that would warrant Microsoft Project.

                In evaluating the potential benefits it is important to focus on additional efficiency savings that could be generated through Microsoft Project software.  I estimate that we should be able to generate an average 3% savings across all companywide projects through the use of Microsoft Project.  This is largely attributed to more tightly controlling budgets and more efficiently assigning resources to project tasks.   Considering our $400 million projects budget a 3% savings amounts to $12 million per year.   There is a likelihood that the savings could eventually reach 5% or $20 million per year over time as experience becomes a greater factor.  The initial incurred costs to implement would be comprised of software licenses as well the productivity losses as discussed earlier.   Individual licenses for Microsoft Project Standard cost $589.99 (4).  By purchasing larger quantities of licenses we could attain a 75% discount on this price.  If we were to purchase a license for all SG&A and R&D employees the cost would come to $663,739.  When we add on top the learning curve related productivity costs of $540,000 the total implementation costs amount to $1,203,139.  Even if we only attain 2% project efficiency savings (as opposed to the 3%) we would still realize a net benefit of approximately $6,800,000 in the first year.

                In conclusion, it is evident that Microsoft Project is smart choice for our company for the following three reasons.  Our existing experience with Microsoft Office gives us a learning curve advantage with Microsoft Project that equates to productivity cost savings of roughly $1 million versus adopting a competitive product.  Our company is a prime candidate for benefiting from project management software due to number, complexity and amount of money we invest in projects.  Finally, when we consider the payoff versus the investment we notice that we would realize a minimum return of $6.8 million in the first year. 

                Please feel free to contact me if you have any further questions or concerns that I could assist with on this topic.

Regards,
Bobby