Monday, April 15, 2013

From Pandora to Profit



            Pandora finds itself at all-important cross roads where the strategic decisions it makes in the next year or two will have a lasting impact on the viability and profit potential of the company.  Pandora founder and chief strategist Tim Westergren has managed to honor his core philosophies while creating a music industry phenomenon.  But in hiring new CEO Joe Kennedy he has come to terms with the fact that Pandora needs to inject strategic creativity to grow substantial revenues.  Since launching in 1999, the user base has ballooned to 8 million now in 2007, and online hours continue to grow at a rate of 50% year over year.  Pandora has proven its worth to advertisers.  Yet the company has failed to produce a profit and fully convince venture capitalists their business model is for real.  Joe and Tim need to drive profitability by amplifying their advertising power, charging fees for upstart musicians, and enhancing the automation of their song coding system.

Pandora earns an effective cost per thousand impressions (CPM) in the $10-13 range, which is considered strong for Web advertising.  Currently this translates to 3.58 cents of advertising revenue per hour.  Pandora has great opportunity to increase these marks to strengthen advertising revenue.  Pandora appeals to advertisers for several reasons.  First is because of the large volumes of users who visit their site.  More importantly, Pandora has the ability to target advertisements at the moments when users interact with the site increasing the likelihood they will see and react to an ad.  And most importantly, Pandora can offer advertisers information about a specific user’s age, gender, zip code and the type of music they listen to which provides valuable personality insights.   Joe and Tim could still increase the advertising value of Pandora by gathering more extensive information on each Pandora user.   Pandora should require each user to fill out a 5 to 10 minute survey containing 50 key questions and insights desired by advertisers.  Acknowledging Pandora’s high level of user loyalty – demonstrated through the 1 million letters they sent to congress to fight license increases—it is doubtful there would be strong outcry or resistance to the survey.  Pandora could even position the survey to its loyal fans as a collaborative effort on their behalf to help keep Pandora a free service for them.  An increase in advertising value from $10-13 CPM to the $14-16 range would translate to a 25% increase in advertising revenue per hour.  With hours doubling year over year this effect would be dramatically compounded.  By implementing the mandatory surveys Pandora could inject further revenues with minimal risk.

Another low risk method for growing revenues includes charging fees to upstart and emerging musicians in exchange for making their music available on Pandora.  Pandora receives several hundred CDs from “unknown” artists every week.  New artists who are able to get on Pandora openly acknowledged the value and benefits they received by doing so.  One artist exclaims, “I just wanted to thank you for putting my music into your system.  I have had sales all over the U.S. and Europe from people who found me via your site…I can’t believe what a promotional tool Pandora has become for my music.”  The dominant record labels are interested only in pursing the exceptionally rare “big-hit” artists. Pandora exists as one of the few mediums available to unknown artists trying to reach the masses of interested listeners.  Pandora needs to be rewarded for opportunities for success it is currently creating for upstart musicians.  There is little risk this strategy would backfire; due to the fact unknown artists have such limited opportunities to pursue in the first place in order to promote their music.   Pandora should institute a $100 charge known as an “entrance fee” per album loaded into their system.  This would generate an additional $2.6 million per year in revenues, assuming Pandora receives 500 new albums per week.

A third strategy involves investing to implement an automated song coding process.  This is important because it has the opportunity to increase the speed at which songs can be added to the Pandora library – meaning higher volumes “entrance fees” which could be processed each period.  This would also have the potential to reduce headcount in the long term.  Currently the coding process relies on a large team of analysts and is a time and labor intensive process.  Currently Pandora employs 100 people, of which we will assume 25 works on the all-important coding process.   Assuming these employees make on average $75,000 this translates to $1,875,000 per year in coding salaries.  If Pandora made a one-time investment of $1 million to develop an automated coding program that could reduce this team to only 5 heads then it would save $375,000 in this first year and  $1.5 million every year going forward.

Pandora is poised to become a profit generating machine that could consume a healthy market share of the music industry.  To realize this potential Pandora needs to implement creative strategies in the immediate future that will increase revenues and profitability.  By enriching the depth and quality of consumer information with mandatory user surveys Pandora could increase its advertising revenues by 25%.  By charging unknown artists an entrance fees they could cash in on the discovery benefits they are currently providing these artists for free.  This would potentially generate $2.6 in additional revenues per year.    Finally, Tim and Joe should invest $1 million in technology to bring serious automation to the coding process which could save the company $6.375 million over the next 5 years.

Regards,
Bobby

No comments:

Post a Comment