Monday, April 22, 2013

Harrah's Reflective



C Level Team,

The consultants did a fine job with their presentation earlier today.  Our company has embraced a strategy that has provided us with results.  We have earned a competitive advantage in the gaming industry by investing heavily in Information systems that provide us with valuable marketing insights.  Our $100 million investment in IT has paid us back with an ROI of 62%.  Meanwhile our competitors have gone a different route by investing nearly a combined $1 billion in extravagant properties yielding an ROI between 15 to 23%.  In light of this success, we really gave this consultant group a difficult challenge by insisting they advise us on how we continue to improve a very high performing company.  We challenged them to come up with intelligent projects that will push us even further ahead of the competition.  The consultants came up with three ideas, which while I feel are good ideas, I believe they are very interdependent on one another.   I also feel there are a few gaps that need to be bridged.  Allow me to explain.

The consultant’s first project recommendation involves increasing our data mining activities.  This calls for further sharpening our focus on the “right” type of customers who have the highest payoff potential.  These are people who typically spend $500 or more per visit and make roughly 3 visits to our casinos per year.  I agree in concept that we can benefit from digging deeper to better understand what the information has to tell us.  However, I feel that in order to perform better analytic than we are currently doing, it will require an up scaled allocation of resources.  This means enhancing the capabilities of both our systems and our people.  The Enterprise server examined in project number three would be a necessity in my belief in order to take our data mining to the next level.  The suggested IBM system would carry a cost of $50,000 to install.  We would also need to hire at least one seasoned analytic expert and provide for further training for our current team members.  I estimate there would be roughly $250,000 in costs for this in the first year, considering the $125,000 salary for the expert and another $5000 to train our other 25 market and data analysts.  Thereafter we would only incur the additional costs of the lead expert’s salary.  I am not arguing against undertaking the data mining project.  I am merely acknowledging that I believe it would require considerable investments beyond the stated costs of the mailing list ($1,250) and marketing efforts ($210 per customer offer).

I am very keen on the second project recommendation to implement the online reservation and concierge.  I think this is a direct way to reach our loyal customers and act as a tool to potentially nudge them to make an additional 4th visit to our casino per year.  An extra visit would mean an additional $500 in revenue per customer.  I think this project would be most effective if coupled with both the first and third projects.  By enhancing our analytics and data mining we could aim to identify the time of year in which a customer might be most vulnerable to make an additional trip to our casino.  Perhaps single people in their 30’s might be more prone to visiting a casino around Valentine’s day.  Or perhaps a married couple who frequents a casino could be a good target during to point this resource to for their Anniversary weekend.  I am confident there are patterns that exist in data we could mine that would allow us to make even more effective use of the online reservation and concierge tool than the consultants suggested.

I would like to consider all three of these projects.  However, I would like to have a better understanding of the total benefit and cost of implementing all three of them in tandem.  I would like to ask if the consultants wouldn’t mind providing us with a high level summary of this request.  I feel we can then take a keener look at what we could expect to incrementally gain from taking these these three projects on all as one.

Regards,
Bobby

No comments:

Post a Comment