Sunday, February 24, 2013

Zara Case Preparation


My fellow executives,

                Our business has consistently been a leader in our industry for net margins having last year surpassed 11% as we grew our net income to 438€ million from 341€ a year ago.   Our company sustains rapid growth as we’ve expanded our footprint across 45 countries and unveil a new store location every day.  This success is a byproduct of our business model, which as you’re aware hinges on our ability to respond immediately to changes in consumer demand and is bolstered by the independence and empowerment of decision making we entrust in our employees.   This business model works because it allows us to respond the quickest to consumers while minimizing our investments in marketing, inventories and IT.   Our IT systems have become a hot topic of discussion as they are now seriously being called into question.   Can we continue to rely on our incredibly dated yet reliable DOS operating system?  Or does the risk our hardware supplier may someday quit producing DOS compatible devices justify a full scale modernization of our operating systems and POS terminals?  I believe that the answer to both of these questions, especially the later, is no.  Rather we should find a position that lies somewhere comfortably in between these alternatives.  It would be prudent for us to continue utilizing our affordable and operationally sound DOS system that continues to meet our essential needs.  We need to simultaneously educate and prepare ourselves for the day we could be forced to transition off DOS.

From a technological perspective our current DOS operating system is prehistoric.  Microsoft, the makers of DOS replaced it 18 years ago—the technology time equivalent of a century—with Windows OS.  DOS does not support most modern functionalities or networking capabilities.  But DOS is however a simple, reliable and inexpensive system.   And for those very reasons DOS is an excellent fit for our business.  The current DOS and POS systems require no IT involvement.  We do not need to send a specialist to new store locations for set up.  We rarely ever receive calls from new or current stores managers related to IT assistance.  The systems are simple enough that our store managers can easily install and reboot them on their own.  DOS and our current POS terminals are fully capable of running our internally built customized software applications supporting our key ordering, fulfillment and manufacturing processes.  The operational stability of DOS has allowed us to keep a minimally staffed IT support function consisting of only 50 people.  By avoiding sophisticated technology upgrades and reducing IT support costs we’ve managed to spend only 0.5% of our total revenues on IT.  On average our competitors invest 2.5%.  This translates to an 80€ million per year cost advantage over our competition generated by our current IT structure.  So why would we consider changing anything with the current system when it’s yielding significant and steady contributions to our bottom line?  The reason is risk.  There is reasonable risk that POS hardware vendors could upgrade their machines to no longer support DOS operating systems.  This would effectively halt our ability to open new stores due to the fact the available POS hardware would not be able to port our customized DOS operated software.  If blind sighted by such a scenario, our minimally staffed IT group would likely not have the capacity in terms of availability nor training to handle an immediate operating system transition.  If we hired a team of 15 specialized professionals at a rate 450€ per person per day it would cost us 844€ thousand and take 6 months to complete the 15,000 hours of required programming time to port the existing POS application to a new OS.   All the meanwhile we would be unable to open new stores. Estimating at one new store opening per day and an average store contribution of $2.5€ million in annual sales our risk exposure could be 450€ to 912€ in lost revenues.  It would be reckless for us to simply ignore such a risk.

The alternative that’s gained the most attention among members in our company involves upgrading to a modern operating system, enhancing the POS application itself and possibly building networks between stores.  Before I touch on the potential benefits, let me first outline the costs associated with this option.  The total estimated cost for completing upgrades to each of our current 1558 stores would be around 23.4€ million.  Going forward the annual recurring costs would be 0.5€ million for all stores.  The breakdown of this would include (in millions) 1.3€ for operating system licenses and maintenance fees, 8.5€ for hardware and connectivity, 1.1€ for programming and 12.5€ for installation and training.  For a company doing nearly 4€ billion in annual sales 23.4€ million may not sound like much, but it’s a serious investment that outweighs the 20€ million we currently spend on IT in a given year.    And each new store would cost approximately 13.5€ thousand to integrate.  These costs are not even the most considerable associated with an upgrade.  A sophisticated system would be more complex and would require far greater internal IT support to maintain.  Store managers would not be proficient in performing the installation and maintenance they currently do with the simple DOS systems.  We would have to further develop and greatly expand our IT function to support the new platform.  While we wouldn’t move into online ordering, it wouldn’t be shocking to estimate an increase of IT costs from 0.5% to 1.5% of our net sales.  This amounts to an additional 40€ million per year.  There are other potential costs that are significant yet difficult to quantify.  These could include time and process inefficiencies related to assimilating store managers and employees to a new sophisticated system.  There is a greater likelihood that a new operating system, while current and powerful would be more susceptible to bugs and crashes than DOS.  As for the benefits to upgrading, the only justifiable reason includes avoiding exposure to a loss of revenues in the event hardware producers discontinue DOS compatibility.   Further benefits are little else but “nice to haves.”  Store managers suggest they would be able to more accurately and efficiently manage their inventories.  I don’t see how this applies to our business model that focuses on maintaining near-zero inventories.  One of our competitive advantages is that our 1,146€ million invested in total current assets—a metric that captures inventory— is considerably lower than that of each of our core competitors.  Why would we place an emphasis on managing inventory when our emphasis is to erase inventories altogether?  I just don’t see the business justification for wireless network supported inventory management tools.

                I believe we should continue to use our DOS operating system for as long as we are able to.  DOS is consistently stable, supports our core competencies and allows us maintain the lowest IT costs in our industry.  We are poised hold an 80€ million annual cost advantage over our competition for every year that we continue riding out the DOS system. Our hardware supplier has not made any indication that they intend to discontinue supporting DOS.  On the other hand, they also refuse to commit by contract that they will continue to support DOS.  Our current exposure to a sudden discontinuation could be upwards to 900€ million in lost revenues resulting from an abrupt halt in store openings.  We should not make a full upgrade at this point.  We should instead take small but meaningful steps to prepare ourselves for a potential scenario where we are forced to move away from DOS.  This can be done by hiring a small team of 5 to 10 IT employees who will focus on testing out new operating systems at a strategic sample of 5 current and 10 new store locations.  I estimate these measures would increase our annual IT spend by at most 5€ million.  This team would be tasked over the next 18 months with completing the necessary 15,000 hours of programing required to port POS applications with the new operating system.  By completing the programing time and creating a specialized IT team capable of leading an upgrade we can alleviate our 900€ million exposure.  We’d also educate ourselves with the sample store test upgrades to be better equipped to handle obstacles in the event we needed to upgrade all our stores.  In this strategic position we’ve now prepared ourselves for a transition, reduced our risk exposure and we can maintain an annual 75€ million in IT cost savings advantage.  This way we get to have our cake and eat it too.      

No comments:

Post a Comment